When Free Software Isn't Free Enough
Summary
The post analyzes a GNU Emacs mailing list debate on whether to accept contributions generated by large language models. It critiques the idea that focusing solely on code freedom is sufficient, arguing that labor, provenance, and broader societal impacts should factor into free software ethics. The author proposes concrete steps for governance, including open policies on LLM contributions, transparency about how code is sourced, and judging patches by process and quality rather than the contributor’s identity.